Great American Writers

17 10 2012

At some point during this most recent term, I began to wonder what makes a great writer. Who decides the criteria? Who determines the candidates? The answers seem illusive.

In my literature class, we read “The Yellow Wallpaper” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman. It always generates strong reactions from students in the class. I was pleasantly surprised that all the men didn’t immediately take John’s side. Several of the women in class are psychology majors or work with mentally ill people and they found the story fascinating.

I’m never fascinated with this story. It makes me angry that a woman could be subjected to a “cure” that makes her crazy. I appreciate my own caring husband more after reading it. Another thing I think is, “Thank the Lord I was born in the 20th century.”

One woman in our literature class berated the story. She claimed the main character was lazy, unmotivated and unappreciative of all the wonderful things her husband did for her. She went on the state how she despised Gilman’s feministic beliefs, especially the way she used men and dumped her daughter off on her first husband instead of mothering her.

Whew! This woman was steaming. I think it’s safe to say that Gilman is not considered a great writer in this lady’s eyes.

We also read “The Open Boat” by Stephen Crane and “To Build a Fire” by Jack London. I think both of these gentlemen are considered to be great American writers. I already spent a post reflecting on Mark Twain’s genius, so I won’t embellish that any further.

We also read “The Other Two” by Edith Wharton, who was considered quite famous during her lifetime.

I’m not sure I can create an active definition from these writers. Obviously, there are similarities in their themes, but what makes them great? There were a dozen or more writers who we read this term, perhaps all of them considered “great American writers.”

Are there great writers producing work even now? Will they be considered great in their lifetime? What criteria will be used to determine their greatness?




One response

17 10 2012

What’s that saying though about one man’s meat is another man’s poison? I used to take literature class at university and I don’t think I appreciated it enough sometimes. I thought people had crazy ideas about books and poems, but in the end it was just how they read them differently to me. I think, ultimately I was only interested in reading books for pleasure, rather than try to find any hidden meaning in them, because I’m lazy like that 😉
Thanks for stopping by on my site too!

Share your thoughts here:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Edits By Stacey

Coaching Authors To Reach Beyond Their Limits

Musings by Connie

Balancing a healthy lifestyle

Christian Creative Nexus

Spiritual Resourcing Hub for Christians Pursuing their Calling

Simply Gracie Girl

Adventuring Since 1997

michelle ziegler

In a world of serious, I write an escape

Roane Publishing Blog

Without authors, there'd be no publishers.

Raw Moments with a Real God

Being Transparent with an Intimate God

Becky Bean Writes

The Blog of Becky: How Not to Live Your Life

Bex Book Nook

Where books like to hang out.

Wendy Sparrow

Where all books have a happily ever after...

The Machenwood Chronicles and Other Tales

A site for writers and readers

Kait Nolan

Smart, sassy, small town Southern romance that makes you feel like home

Jennifer M Eaton

Author, Weaver of Tales

The Mom Pages

Sharing The Mom Life One Page at a Time

Kelly Roberts Writing

Cooking with bubble wrap

YA Chit Chat

The Ponderings of YA author J. Keller Ford

Melissa Kircher

Artist and Writer for Hire | Helping You Make Your World More Bold and Beautiful

Gwen Hernandez

Author of romantic suspense. Scrivener expert.

%d bloggers like this: